Four managers came together once again for a face-to-face Season Ticket Baseball showdown, and some of the skippers were waxing nostalgically about the long ball after our deadball gathering the last time around. So we jumped 76 years ahead to 1991, where there were four teams in the American League separated by just a single game in the final standings - the Athletics, Brewers, Red Sox and Tigers. So it's off to the era of the Gulf War, the dissolution of the Soviet Union and Michael Jordan's first NBA title, for a double round-robin FTF tournament with no playoffs - winner takes all!

| Manager | Team | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Joe Costa | 1991 Boston Red Sox (84-78) |
| 2 | Bob Militello | 1991 Milwaukee Brewers (83-79) |
| 3 | Fred Steffens | 1991 Oakland Athletics (84-78) |
| 4 | Scott Needle | 1991 Detroit Tigers (84-78) |
- 25-man roster, named prior to start of tournament
- Pitchers must have 15+ GS to start
- Position players with less than 150 AB may not start; they are eligible to PH at any time, but may only stay in the game (or enter as defensive replacement) in 6th inning or later, and pitchers may not pinch hit or pinch run unless they did so in real life
- Starting pitchers (i.e., no relief Stamina rating) who are not used to start may relieve with a relief Stamina equal to one-half their starting value (rounded down), but they can only be used (1) when the original starter hits a Fatigue of 4, or (2) the game is in extra innings
- Pitcher injuries will be ignored, and any other injuries are in force for the remainder of the current game ONLY; if a player is injured (or ejected), his replacement is not subject to limits specified above.
- Season Ticket “Season Play” pitcher fatigue rules (page 28 of the Rules) will govern usage and in-game Fatigue; the “Pitching on Short Rest” rule will be in effect for pitchers who qualify.
- Designated hitter rule in effect for home games of DH-era teams
- No zombie runner in extra innings
- Games tied after twelve innings are recorded as ties in the standings
Once the managers had arrived at the tournament site and the lineups had been considered, the rotations weighed, and the competition sized up, the dice rolling began . . .
Detroit rallied all the way back from a big early deficit, only to see the Brewers snatch the victory back in their final at-bat. The teams traded 2nd-inning runs before Milwaukee exploded for five runs in the 3rd. After Robin Yount reached on a Dave Bergman error to start the inning, the next three Brewers stroked base hits with Bill Spiers pushing the first runs across with a two-run double. After Tanana struck out Greg Vaughn with two men in scoring position, Franklin Stubbs crushed one into the RF seats for three more runs and a 6-1 Milwaukee lead. Tempers flared in the top of the 3rd when Mickey Tettleton came in hot at second base trying to break up a double play on Cecil Fielder's grounder, Willie Randolph objected to his enthusiasm, and the two players exchanged shoves. After the benches emptied and more pushing and vicious staredowns ensued, the two antagonists were ejected. The score stayed still until the 5th, when Detroit finally began to figure out Navarro - Lou Whitaker led off with a double, Tony Phillips singled him home, and Fielder singled across Phillips one out later. A run-scoring ground out made it 6-4 by the end of the inning, and the visitors completed the comeback in the next frame when Milt Cuyler singled with one out and Phillips then homered two batters later. The bullpens tightened things up, with no baserunners for either side in the 7th; Detroit's lead-off walk in the 8th chased Navarro, but Julio Machado came on and quickly erased that on Travis Fryman's double-play ball back to the box. In the bottom of the 8th, Jerry Don Gleaton retired the first batter, but Yount ripped one into the gap and didn't stop running until he had reached third base safely. Gleaton whiffed Dale Sveum for the second out, but Paul Molitor jumped on a fastball for a double that gave the home team the lead again. Machado allowed a one-out walk to Phillips in the 9th, but B.J. Surhoff gunned him down attempting to steal his way into scoring position and substitute catcher Andy Allanson dribbled one back to the mound for the game's final out. Milwaukee 7-13-1, Detroit 6-9-1. [box] [pbp]
Greg Harris improbably survived 6.2 innings of tightrope walking and Tom Brunansky knocked in a pair of runs to lead the Sox. A brace of 1st-inning singles gave Boston a quick lead, but a bases-loaded walk by Harris to Mike Gallego in the 3rd gave it back; the visitors pushed out in front again in the nest half-inning on a Jack Clark double, Ellis Burks single and Brunansky's fielder's choice. The game stayed in this state until the 8th inning, despite Harris allowing 17 of the 35 men he faced to reach base, as he held the As to 0-for-10 batting with runners in scoring position and the home team would strand 15 men on the afternoon. With Boston still clinging to the one-run lead, Brunansky delivered a big two-out RBI double in the 8th, Carlos Quintana followed with a single that provided some insurance, and The Two Jeffs (Gray and Reardon) pitched 2.1 innings of one-hit baseball to nail down the win. Boston 4-10-1, Oakland 1-10-1. [box] [pbp]
A B.J. Surhoff grand slam keyed a five-run 8th inning that catapulted Milwaukee to victory, as Chris Bosio pitched seven strong innings after a shaky start. A pair of 1st-inning singles got the Red Sox rolling with one out before Jim Gantner couldn't grasp Jack Clark's bouncer to third base as one run scored and, one out later, Tom Bruanansky jerked a two-run double down the left-field line. The early lead stretched as far as 4-1 in favor of Boston, and Clemens appeared comfortable (if not dominant) until he allowed singles to the first two Brewers in the 8th. That brought in Tony Fossas to face the left-handed underbelly of the MIL lineup but, despite five of the next six hitters standing in on the port side, the Red Sox LOOGY couldn't get it done; a Bill Spiers squeeze bunt scored the tying run, then a Robin Yount single and a walk to Franklin Stubbs filled the bases full for Surhoff. The Milwaukee catcher drove a Fossas fastball into the RF stands for four runs and a 8-4 Milwaukee lead. Bosio allowed eleven hits, but ten of those were singles and he kept a clean sheet for six innings before being relieved by Julio Machado and Edwin Nunez. Three different Brewers (Spiers, Paul Molitor, Daryl Hamilton) had three base hits each. Milwaukee 9-16-1, Boston 5-13-0. [box] [pbp]
Mark McGwire's three-run bomb in the 6th inning gave Oakland its first lead of the game and Welch and three relievers held off Detroit the rest of the way, getting a game-ending ground ball double play with the tying runs aboard in the bottom of the 9th. Things started very poorly for the As and for Gullickson when the first three Tiger hitters in the bottom of the 1st went double-single-homer, Mickey Tettleton doing the long-ball honors, but the Oakland starter weathered the storm as his teammates worked their way back into the game. Two singles and a walk set up a McGwire ground ball RBI in the 4th, and then Harold Baines and Jose Canseco started the 6th with base hits as well. After Gullickson retired Dave Henderson on a ground out to move the runners along, he opted to pitch to McGwire and paid the price, watching a colossal drive to left field put the visitors ahead by a score of 4 to 3. Canseco and Lou Whitaker exchanged solo shots in the 8th, and Rickey Henderson's two-out RBI single gave Oakland a two-run cushion in the 9th. Dennis Eckersley came on in the bottom of the inning and immediately put two Tigers on base, including an uncharacteristic base on balls, but induced a harmless fly ball to left off the bat of Alan Trammell for the first out. That brought Travis Fryman to the plate and he pounded one into the ground right at Mike Gallego, who turned the routine 643 twin-killing to end the ballgame. McGwire finished with four RBI, and Whitaker with three base hits. Oakland 6-10-1, Detroit 4-10-0. [box] [pbp]
Boston batters buried Detroit under twenty-one hits, none for extra bases, and scored in six consecutive innings on their way to a lopsided win. Four 2nd-inning runs got the parade started for the Red Sox, Wade Boggs (4-for-6, 3B, two HR, four RBI) singling in a pair, and that started an avalanche of big swings for Boston. Tom Brunansky doubled in three straight innings, scoring twice and driving in one, and the Sox punctuated the barrage with home runs from Boggs and Luis Rivera in the 8th. The visitors finished with four doubles, two triples and three home runs while Gardiner pitched five shutout innings before wilting in the 6th after the game was already out of hand. Mickey Tettleton had a double, homer and three RBI in the losing cause. Boston 11-21-1, Detroit 5-10-2. [box] [pbp]
Ernie Riles hit a dramatic 9th-inning home run to give Oakland the final upper hand in a see-saw affair in Milwaukee. Jose Canseco hit a two-run homer in the 4th to put the As on top, but the Brew Crew answered immediately in their half on a Jim Gantner triple, a catcher's interference call on Jamie Quirk, and RBI singles from B.J. Surhoff and Willie Randolph. But the visitors came right back with another pair in their next at-bat, a big error by Randolph setting the stage for Harold Baines' two-out, two-run single. That lead also didn't last long - in the Milwaukee 6th, after Dave Stewart had retired the first two men, Stubbs walked, Surhoff singled him home and Paul Molitor doubled Surhoff across to tie the game. The Brewer catcher was again the focal point when the home team took the lead for the first time in the 8th, doubling in the go-ahead run after Robin Yount had walked and Stubbs had singled. Doug Henry was summoned to lock it up for Milwaukee and he quickly fanned McGwire and retired Dave Henderson on a fly ball to center. But Quirk singled and that was the beginning of the end - Willie Wilson pinch-ran, stole second and took third on Surhoff's errant peg, and then danced home as Riles followed with a fly ball down the right field line that got into the fifth row of the seats for the game-deciding swing. Curt Young, left in the game after an 8th inning in which he allowed three of the five men he faced to reach base, walked Daryl Hamilton aboard with one out but popped up Greg Vaughn and fanned pinch-hitter Dale Sveum for the final out of the game. Randolph and Surhoff had three hits apiece, and Bill Wegman (8 ip, 3 h) probably deserved a kinder fate. Oakland 6-5-2, Milwaukee 5-13-2. [box] [pbp]
![]() |
| Ernie Riles wins it with a deep drive to right field |
After the rest day, the action continued . . .
Wade Boggs had three more hits and knocked in two runs, and Joe Hesketh pitched 5.1 innings of one-hit baseball for the Red Sox at County Stadium. The Sox struck first when, after two men were retired in the 3rd, they whacked August around for four straight hits which (with the help of Greg Vaughn's error in left) scored three runs. But that was essentially it for the offenses in the early going, in fact the Brewers couldn't manage a single base hit off of Hesketh over the first five innings. In the 6th, though, the Boston starter began to run into problems, walking Bill Spiers with one out and then watching a long Franklin Stubbs fly ball rattle around in center for a two-out RBI triple. With the tying run at the plate, Hesketh departed despite the one-hitter and Dennis Lamp retired PH Daryl Hamilton on a comebacker to short-circuit the threat. Three singles in the top of the 7th, the third off the bat of Ellis Burks with two away, gave Boston an extra run's worth of breathing space, but Boggs' error in the bottom half led to an unearned run which made it a two-run game once again. The edge doubled in the 8th as the visitors scored twice on three more one-base hits, Boggs knocking in the first run with his single and Jody Reed adding a sacrifice fly. From there, it was another lights-out performance by the back end of the Boston bullpen as Jeff Gray, Tom Bolton and Jeff Reardon tag-teamed 2.1 scoreless innings. Not that there wasn't any drama - Bolton put two on with two outs in the 9th before Reardon came on to douse the flames with a swinging third strike to Willie Randolph. Boston 6-14-1, Milwaukee 2-4-2. [box] [pbp]
The two clubs combined to blast six home runs, but all of the other hitting came from the Tigers as they pounded Oakland pitching for twenty hits and seven walks on their way to a big win. There was little sign in the early going of the carnage that was to follow, as the visitors led just 2-1 after the first three frames with Detroit scoring on a passed ball and a Travis Fryman double while Oakland countered with Jose Canseco's 1st-inning solo shot. But it started to come a cropper for the Athletics in the 4th - Dave Bergman led off with a homer and Slusarski walked the next three Tigers before Milt Cuyler singled and Lou Whitaker lofted a sac fly to make it a 5-1 game. There was more in the 5th when Bergman (3-for-5, three runs scored) again began proceedings with a base hit; it looked as if he would be stranded there but, with two outs, Fryman tripled, Cuyler singled and it was quickly a six-run Detroit bulge. Mickey Tettleton's homer made it 9-1 in the 6th before Oakland showed some resistance; Mark McGwire and Harold Baines each hit two-rum blasts to help reduce the deficit to 10-5, but it took four As pitchers to get through the top of the 9th (one of whom wasn't a pitcher at all, but infielder Vance Law who faced three batters while allowing a single and a wild pitch) as the Bengals piled on five more runs behind Cecil Fielder's bases-loaded double and Lloyd Moseby's two-run homer. Leiter pitched seven solid innings before yielding to the mop-up crew, and four Tigers finished the game with three hits to their name. Detroit 15-20-0, Oakland 7-11-1. [box] [pbp]
Greg Harris and three relievers stymied the Tigers on eight hits, and Luis Rivera (three hits) and Ellis Burks (three RBI) led the Boston offense at Fenway Park. Detroit, who had whacked twenty base hits the day before, could not find the big one against Harris, who allowed seven baserunners over the first five innings but had stranded every last one of them. The Sox, meanwhile weren't faring any better against Tanana, collecting just two hits in those five innings while making nine infield outs. but the 6th inning proved fatal to both Frank and to Detroit; Mike Greenwell led off with a single, and a Rivera hit and Tony Peña walk filled the bases for Wade Boggs with two outs. The way his tournament had gone thus far, the outcome was predictable, and the Boston third sacker lined one into center field that scored the first two runs of the game. Harris tightened things up in the next few innings, and didn't leave the game until allowing a two-out double to Dave Bergman in the 7th. Tony Fossas put away pinch-hitter Skeeter Barnes to end the inning, and then Boston salted away the game after the stretch. Tanana coughed up two-base hits to Boggs and Jody Reed to start the inning for Boston and Dan Gakeler could only get one out before allowing three straight hit, the third one a three-run tater by Burks that made the score 7-0. Dennis Lamp managed to load the bases in the top of the 9th, but Tom Bolton got danger man Mickey Tettleton to ground out to short for the game's final out as the Sox clinched the Showdown title. Boston 7-11-0, Detroit 0-8-0. [box] [pbp]
Rickey Henderson's grand slam capped a five-run 5th inning that was enough to back Mike Moore's solid mound work as Oakland topped Milwaukee. The visitors had jumped to a 2-0 lead on RBI hits from Willie Randolph and Jim Gantner, and Navarro took the mound for the home half of the 5th having allowed only a Mike Gallego double in the first four frames. But the first two As singled, and then Lance Blankenship loaded the bases when Jamie Quirk beat the throw to third base on his sacrifice bunt attempt. Gallego singled to score the first Oakland run, and Rickey then drilled one into the RF seats for the four-run swing. Moore wasn't overpowering - seven hits and four walks in six innings - but the Brewers went only 2-for-11 with runners in scoring position. Trailing 6-2 in the 9th, they loaded the bases with two outs, bringing Joe Klink out of the pen to face pinch-hitter Dante Bichette as the potential tying run and the young outfielder could only ground one up the first-base line where Mark McGwire was waiting to field the ball and step on the bag to end the game. Randolph, Quirk and Franklin Stubbs each produced three base hits. Oakland 6-9-0, Milwaukee 2-9-2. [box] [pbp]
After a decent opening outing in which he was let down heavily by his bullpen, Clemens stifled Oakland for 7.1 innings and two hits apiece from Wade Boggs and Jack Clark were enough to ensure Boston's fifth win in six tries. Mark McGwire's third homer of the tournament, leading off the 2nd, gave the visitors an early lead but Ellis Burks reciprocated with a two-out bases-empty blast in the 6th to tie the game. To that point Welch, who had escaped a bases-loaded one-out mess in the 1st, had pitched even better than the Rocket, but the quality work on the hill wouldn't last for Oakland. Welch gave up a leadoff single to Tom Brunansky in the 6th and was pulled, but it took four Athletics relievers to get through the rest of the inning - Tony Peña, Boggs and Clark each singled home a run to give Clemens a three-run lead, and Jeff Gray retired the last five men in order with just one ball leaving the infield as Boston slammed the door.. Boston 4-8-0, Oakland 1-5-0 [box] [pbp]
The Tigers could collect only four base hits, but all four of them came in two innings, three of them went for extra bases and two Brewer errors helped them turn those hits into just enough scoring to win on the road. A Greg Vaughn RBI hit had given the Brew Crew the lead in the top of the 4th, but Willie Randolph's miscue on a Lou Whitaker grass-cutter to begin the bottom half started the ball rolling for Detroit. Tony Phillips and Mickey Tettleton followed with back-to-back triples, the first Tiger hits of the game, Cecil Fielder followed with a run-scoring fly ball and the Tigers had a 3-1 lead. Alan Trammell's solo homer in the 5th made it 4-1, but Milwaukee battled back to within a run after Paul Molitor went deep for a pair of runs in the top of the 6th. Brewer pitching tightened the screws in the late innings, retiring the final eleven Tigers - six by way of the strikeout - but they couldn't find a way through Gullickson, who set down nine of ten before Mike Henneman was summoned for the 9th inning. He walked Dale Sveum to out the tying run aboard to start the inning, and Greg Brock singled as a pinch-hitter with two outs, but Franklin Stubbs popped up to second base and that was the ballgame. Bosio was something of a hard-luck loser, going the distance allowing four hits and one walk against nine strikeouts for Milwaukee. Detroit 4-4-0, Milwaukee 3-7-2. [box] [pbp]
![]() |
| Alan Trammell's 5th-inning homer proved to be the deciding run |
Final Standings
| Team | W | L | T | PCT | GB | RDiff | Home | Away |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1991 Boston Red Sox | 5 | 1 | 0 | 0.833 | 0.0 | 19 | 2-1 | 3-0 |
| 1991 Oakland Athletics | 3 | 3 | 0 | 0.500 | 2.0 | -7 | 1-2 | 2-1 |
| 1991 Milwaukee Brewers | 2 | 4 | 0 | 0.333 | 3.0 | -5 | 1-2 | 1-2 |
| 1991 Detroit Tigers | 2 | 4 | 0 | 0.333 | 3.0 | -7 | 1-2 | 1-2 |
It was offense they wanted, and it was offense they got as the four teams combined to hit .291 with 26 homers, and average more than five runs per game. Boston really dominated from pillar-to-post, slashing 341/375/482 with seven of their nine regulars hitting over .300, and also leading the way with 2.50 ERA that was two full runs less than Milwaukee's second-best - there was a fair bit of smoke-and mirrors beneath this as a 1.41 WHIP and the second-most walks allowed implied a lot of stranded baserunners, but they allowed only three home runs in 54 innings. [Tournament stats]
1B: Dave Bergman, 1991 Tigers (2)
2B: Willie Randolph, 1991 Brewers (2)
SS: Luis Rivera, 1991 Red Sox (4)
3B: Wade Boggs, 1991 Red Sox (4)
After going just 1-for-5 in the tournament opener, Red Sox 3B Wade Boggs was simply unstoppable. He hit .500 over the final five games to finish at 444/483/815, leading the Showdown in hits, RBI and OPS.
Showdown History













0 comments:
Post a Comment